Resources
Self-Insured Retention (SIR)
What a self-insured retention is, how an SIR differs from a deductible, where it sits under an umbrella and why clients ask about it in their contracts.
What a self-insured retention is
A self-insured retention is a layer of loss the business agrees to carry on its own, underneath its liability policy. Until claims use up that layer, the insurer has no part in them; the business pays the damages and the defense itself, and only then does the policy take over. Los Angeles County’s insurance manual describes a retention as a self-insured layer below the liability limits that resembles a deductible, and the California Department of Insurance treats it as the share of a property or liability loss the policyholder keeps.
How an SIR works on a claim
Under the County of Sonoma’s comparison chart, a claim that stays inside the retention is the business’s to handle: it pays the claim and the defense costs until the SIR is exhausted, after which the insurer covers the remaining defense costs. The limit behaves differently too. Once the business has paid its retention, the insurer answers for the full policy limit, because the SIR sits below the limit rather than being carved out of it.
Retentions show up on umbrellas as well. California’s Insurance Code defines a commercial umbrella as liability coverage written over underlying policies or over a stated self-insured retention, and the Department of Insurance explains that when an umbrella picks up a loss with no underlying policy in force, a retention applies first. Our umbrella vs. excess liability guide shows where that layer sits, and how to save on commercial umbrella insurance covers retentions when pricing an umbrella.
SIR vs deductible
| Question | Deductible | Self-insured retention |
|---|---|---|
| Who handles and pays the claim first | The insurer, which then bills the business | The business, until the retention is used up |
| Defense costs | Set by the wording: damages only, or damages and defense | Paid by the business inside the retention |
| Effect on the limit | Reduces what the insurer pays within the limit | Sits below the limit, so the full limit stays available |
| On a certificate | Generally not needed | Should be shown |
The last row explains why clients care. With a deductible, the insurer carries the risk that the business cannot repay, so a claimant still gets paid. With an SIR, nothing comes from the insurer until the retention is spent, so anyone relying on the policy wants to know how big that first layer is.
An SIR is also not the same as being self-insured. A retention is a layer under a commercial policy, while carrying your own workers’ comp in California is a separate status that needs a certificate of consent from the Department of Industrial Relations’ Office of Self-Insurance Plans, as California workers’ comp basics for employers explains.
Why clients ask about your SIR
Public buyers write retentions into their contracts. Los Angeles County’s insurance manual, as one example, makes contractors declare any SIR and lets the County require it reduced, removed as far as the County is concerned, or backed by a bond guaranteeing payment of the retention along with claims investigation, administration and defense costs. Policies must not leave the County owing any part of the retention, and certificates must show the amount of any deductible or SIR. That is one county’s approach rather than a statewide rule; our guide to insurance requirements in client contracts and the contractor requirements by trade page show where such clauses turn up.
On residential construction wrap-ups, California law lets a builder ask an enrolled subcontractor to put money toward the program’s retention only within disclosure, proportion and notice limits, and the total collected cannot exceed the SIR due; see OCIP and CCIP. Before signing a contract that caps deductibles or retentions at a stated amount, check your policy and ask a licensed broker-agent how your retention wording measures up.
Get help
Facing a contract that asks you to disclose or cap your retention? Send the insurance section to Mithril1 and we will set it beside your liability and umbrella wording. More terms are in the glossary.
A few useful answers
Common questions
Does an SIR reduce my policy limit?
No. The retention sits underneath the limit. After the business pays through its SIR, the insurer answers for the full limit, unlike a deductible, which comes out of what the insurer pays.
Who pays defense costs inside a self-insured retention?
The business. It pays both the claim and the cost of defending it until the retention is used up; from that point the insurer covers the remaining defense costs.
Why does a client want my SIR on the certificate?
Because the insurer pays nothing on a claim until the retention is spent. A client counting on your policy needs to know how large that first layer is, and some public buyers, Los Angeles County among them, require certificates to show it.
Is having an SIR the same as being self-insured?
No. An SIR is a layer below a commercial policy. Self-insuring workers’ comp in California is a separate status that requires a certificate of consent from the Department of Industrial Relations’ Office of Self-Insurance Plans.
Services
