Skip to content

Resources

Insurance Deductible

How a deductible works on business property and liability insurance, how to choose a level the business can carry, and how it differs from a self-insured retention.

Get a quote

What a deductible is

A deductible is the slice of a covered loss that stays with the business before the insurer’s money comes in. On commercial policies it is normally a set dollar amount, and once it has been met the insurer pays the covered loss up to the policy limit. It is picked when the policy is written and is priced into the rate.

How a deductible works on property and liability

On property coverage the arithmetic is straightforward: the covered loss is measured, the deductible comes off, and the insurer pays the rest within the limit. As NAIC’s homeowners example shows, a property deductible can be written as a dollar figure or as a percentage, and separate coverages on one policy can each carry their own, so ask how every deductible on your policy applies.

Liability deductibles run the other way round. According to a County of Sonoma chart comparing the two structures, the insurer normally handles and pays a liability claim from the first dollar, then bills the business for the deductible. Whether that deductible reaches damages alone or damages plus defense costs varies from policy to policy, so read the deductible wording itself. The deductible also comes out of the limit: the most the insurer pays is the limit less the deductible.

Choosing a deductible

A higher deductible brings the rate and the premium down, which makes it tempting. The California Department of Insurance cautions against choosing one so large it threatens the business’s finances, and suggests asking your broker-agent which options exist. Los Angeles County’s contract manual makes the same point from the buyer’s side, observing that small or new companies often cannot set aside enough to fund a large deductible. Our guide on how to save on business insurance weighs deductibles against other savings, and saving on commercial property insurance looks at property deductibles in detail.

Each deductible you carry is shown on the declarations page. If a California commercial insurer will only renew with higher deductibles, it has to warn you in writing between 60 and 120 days before the policy period closes, which leaves time to shop or adjust.

Deductible vs self-insured retention

Contracts often blur these two. With a deductible, the insurer runs the claim, pays it and then collects the deductible from the business. Because the insurer, not the claimant, carries the risk that the business never repays, a deductible generally does not need to appear on a certificate. With a self-insured retention, the business pays the claim and its defense first, and the insurer comes in only once the retention is spent.

Client contracts reach deductibles as well. Los Angeles County, for one, makes contractors declare their deductibles and retentions, can require them reduced, removed as to the County or backed by a bond, and expects them to apply per occurrence or per loss, or per claim on professional liability. That is one county’s practice, not California law; our guide to insurance requirements in client contracts shows how to read clauses like it.

On residential construction wrap-ups, California law limits when a builder or general contractor can ask an enrolled subcontractor to help pay the program’s deductible. The maximum and the way it is collected must be spelled out in the subcontract, the share has to be reasonably limited and in line with claims from that sub’s work, it can be collected only once the deductible is actually incurred, written notice is required, and total contributions cannot top the deductible owed. More on those programs: OCIP and CCIP.

Get help

Weighing a higher deductible, or a contract that limits yours? Talk it through with Mithril1 before you commit. More definitions are in the insurance glossary.

A few useful answers

Common questions

Does a higher deductible lower my premium?

Yes. Deductibles are built into the rate, so raising one lowers the rate and premium. The California Department of Insurance advises picking a level the business can pay from its own funds after a loss.

Who pays first on a liability claim with a deductible?

The insurer. On a liability deductible it normally pays the claim from the first dollar and then bills the business for the deductible amount.

Is a deductible the same as a self-insured retention?

No. Under a retention the business pays the claim and the defense costs on its own until the retention is used up, and the insurer pays after that. A retention also sits below the limit, while a deductible comes out of it.

Can one policy have more than one deductible?

Yes. Separate coverages on one policy can each carry a deductible, and some property deductibles are written as a percentage rather than a dollar figure. Your declarations page lists every one.