Surplus Lines Insurance in California
When standard insurers turn a California business down, surplus lines insurance is often the next market to try. This guide explains how non-admitted insurers work, what they cost in taxes and fees, and what protection you give up.
What is surplus lines insurance?
Surplus lines insurance is coverage written by an insurer that is not licensed by the California Department of Insurance. The Insurance Code calls these companies nonadmitted insurers, and the Department describes them as the non-admitted market. They are not unregulated outsiders: each one has to pass an approval process before brokers can use it, but the Department’s control over how they operate is limited.
The market exists for risks the standard insurers decline or will not price. Their rates are not regulated the way admitted carriers’ rates are, which is part of what lets them take on a cannabis store, an armed guard firm or a business coming off a rough claims year. Because each insurer sets its own terms, reading the exclusions on these policies matters more than usual.
Admitted and non-admitted insurers
An admitted insurer holds a California license for the line it sells. It answers to California’s solvency regulation, and its policyholders fall under the state’s guarantee fund if it fails. Most business owners never deal with any other kind, because most businesses have no trouble finding cover in the standard market.
Non-admitted insurance trades some of that protection for availability. A surplus lines insurer based in another U.S. state must be licensed for the line in its home state and hold capital and surplus of $45,000,000, with a lower figure allowed only on a specific finding by the Commissioner, and never below $4,500,000 (Insurance Code 1765.1). Insurers based outside the United States must appear on the NAIC’s Quarterly Listing of Alien Insurers. The Department also posts a List of Approved Surplus Line Insurers, known as the LASLI, and the Surplus Line Association of California offers a lookup of insurers on it.
When a business ends up in the surplus lines market
The Department’s commercial insurance guide names the two usual paths: significant losses, or operations an insurer sees as high risk. In practice that covers a lot of ground. Cannabis is the clearest case; a 2022 Senate Insurance Committee analysis found most cannabis retailers buy their cover from surplus lines insurers, as our cannabis dispensary insurance page explains. Some security guard products are written only on a non-admitted basis, which the security guard company insurance page covers.
Other common routes are contractors whose trades several admitted insurers avoid, a new venture with no track record in a risky field, and an owner whose policy was not renewed after a run of claims. High risk business insurance is not a separate product; it is usually ordinary general liability or property cover written by a surplus lines company on its own terms. Our guide to what underwriters look at shows the factors that push a file out of the standard market.
The diligent search and three declinations
California expects the admitted market to be tried first. Before a broker places cover with a nonadmitted insurer, Insurance Code 1763 requires a diligent search among admitted insurers that actually write that kind of insurance, and a signed form describing the search and what came of it. The search is presumed done when three of those admitted insurers have declined the risk, or when fewer than three write it at all. The Commissioner can order a broader search for similar placements later.
Very large organizations can skip the search with a written disclosure and their own written request, but the test is built for big buyers: a qualified risk manager, more than $100,000 a year in property and casualty premium, and size such as revenue above $50,000,000. Small businesses go through the declination step, so expect your broker to ask for the decline letters or emails you already have.
Surplus lines tax and stamping fee
A surplus lines quote comes with state charges you will not see itemized on most admitted policies. Under Insurance Code 1775.5 the surplus line broker pays the state a tax of 3 percent of gross premiums charged, less return premiums, and the Surplus Line Association of California states that 3% is the current rate. The Association also charges a stamping fee, 0.18% since January 1, 2023.
The tax base is wider than the premium line alone. The Association’s guidance treats charges the insurer requires, such as policy fees and inspection fees, as taxable premium too. When comparing a non-admitted quote with an admitted one, add the tax, the stamping fee and any policy or broker fees so you are looking at the full yearly cost.
No CIGA protection, and the notice you sign
The biggest trade-off is what happens if the insurer fails. The California Insurance Guarantee Association, CIGA, steps in for claims against insolvent admitted insurers, and the Department states it does not apply to surplus line insurers. If a non-admitted company becomes insolvent, the Department says the insured’s only route is through the courts. That makes the insurer’s financial strength a fair question to ask before you bind.
You will see this in writing. Insurance Code 1764.1 requires a disclosure printed in boldface 16-point type on a freestanding document, telling you the insurer is outside California’s solvency regulation and its guarantee funds. You sign it when a new application is accepted, and the same statement appears on the front of the policy. An applicant who never received and signed it can cancel on a pro rata basis and get back any broker fees.
How we request surplus lines quotes
Mithril1 reaches surplus lines insurers through wholesale brokers who hold the surplus line license the Department requires. When the admitted carriers we work with decline a risk, we send the file to a wholesaler, which takes it to the non-admitted market; each surplus lines insurer decides whether to quote after its own review. Our agency, brokerage and carrier guide explains how those roles fit together.
A business that has just been non-renewed should start gathering papers right away. Ask the current insurer for loss runs covering the last several years; our loss runs guide explains what they show. Add the non-renewal notice, any decline letters, a plain description of operations, revenue and payroll figures, and what has changed since the claims, such as new training, cameras or contracts. A clear story about how a problem was fixed is often what an underwriter reads most closely.
A few useful answers
Common questions
What is surplus lines insurance in California?
It is coverage from an insurer not licensed by the California Department of Insurance, reached through a broker with a surplus line license. It is used for risks that standard admitted insurers decline or will not price.
Is non-admitted insurance legal and safe to buy?
It is legal when the insurer meets California’s eligibility rules and the broker follows the placement rules. The main difference is protection: CIGA does not cover these insurers, so their own financial strength matters more.
What taxes and fees come with a surplus lines policy?
The broker pays a 3 percent state tax on the premium under Insurance Code 1775.5, plus a 0.18% stamping fee to the Surplus Line Association of California. Insurer-required policy and inspection fees are taxed as premium too.
Do I need three declinations before going to surplus lines?
For most small businesses, yes in effect. Insurance Code 1763 presumes a diligent search was made once three admitted insurers that write the cover have declined, or when fewer than three write it.
Can Mithril1 help after my insurer non-renews my business?
It can, by working with a wholesale broker to request quotes from surplus lines insurers once the admitted market has declined. Whether a policy follows is up to each insurer after it reviews your loss runs and operations.
