Premium Audits Explained
A premium audit is how your insurer swaps the payroll or sales you estimated at the start of a policy for the real numbers once the term is over. Here is what a workers comp audit looks at, which records to have ready and what to do when the result looks wrong.
What is a workers comp audit?
Your workers’ comp premium is priced up front on an estimate: the payroll you expect to pay in each class code, multiplied by the rate for that class. California’s Department of Insurance (CDI) points out that the final premium cannot be calculated until the term is over, because only then is the actual payroll known. The audit closes that gap. When payroll came in higher than the estimate, you owe additional premium; when it came in lower, the insurer returns the difference.
The auditor also checks that your class codes match the work your people actually did, which is often where the larger swings come from. The California class code guide explains how codes are assigned.
On timing, CDI says insurers generally may audit payroll during the policy period and for up to three years after it ends, and the WCIRB holds its own right to audit an employer’s payroll records. State Fund audits after the term expires or the policy is cancelled, and a cancelled policy is still audited for the months it was in force.
Field audits and virtual audits
Each insurer decides how it runs a premium audit. State Fund’s 2026 premium audit guide names two kinds. In a field audit, a State Fund auditor or an outside audit vendor reviews the records on site and may look over the business locations. In a virtual audit, you send the supporting records, such as payroll reports and quarterly tax returns, through State Fund’s online audit portal. A State Fund audit starts with an appointment letter that names any special requirements for your policy.
Private insurers use their own forms and methods, so ask the auditor which records and dates they need. For how the two kinds of insurer differ, see State Fund vs private workers’ comp.
Records to have ready for a premium audit
The list below follows State Fund’s checklist, and most auditors ask for something close to it:
- Payroll journals or registers and employee earnings records, with gross pay broken out by class code and overtime shown on its own line
- Federal Forms 940 and 941, W-2 and W-3, and 1096 and 1099
- California quarterly wage reports (DE 9 and DE 9C)
- Your federal income tax return, general ledger, check register, bank statements and profit and loss statement
- A list of officers, clerical employees and outside salespersons, with each person’s duties
- Certificates of insurance for every subcontractor, covering the dates they worked for you
A few habits make audit day smoother. Show overtime separately: the extra pay above the regular rate does not count toward premium, and the auditor can only credit it when it is visible. If you pay anyone in cash, keep a log of names, dates, hours and amounts; State Fund warns that without one, every cash withdrawal from the bank account may be counted. Construction employers who split one worker’s pay between trades need time cards showing the hours in each, or the WCIRB rules put the whole wage in the highest-rated class that applies. And report big payroll changes as they happen: State Fund notes the estimate can be revised mid-term, with any added premium spread over installments.
Uninsured subcontractors added at audit
This is the charge that surprises contractors most. When you hire a subcontractor who carries no workers’ comp of their own, the auditor can treat that sub’s workers as yours for premium purposes. State Fund’s guide says that to avoid the charge you need proof of the sub’s own policy or exemption, plus a valid license where state law requires one. In construction, a person doing licensed work without a contractor’s license counts as an employee, and the premium follows the trade performed and the amounts paid, which State Fund describes as potentially substantial.
Payments to uninsured or unlicensed workers that you reported on 1099s can be added to audited payroll too, decided case by case. The remedy is collecting a certificate before work starts and checking its dates. The guides to insurance for subcontractors and the certificate of insurance cover what to request, and employees vs independent contractors in California covers the classification question underneath it.
General liability audits on payroll or sales
Workers’ comp is not the only policy that gets audited. IRMI defines a premium audit as a review, after the policy period, of whatever exposure the policy is rated on, such as payroll, sales or vehicle count. When a general liability policy is rated on payroll or gross sales, the same true-up applies: the estimate used to price the policy gives way to the actual figure once the year ends.
Payroll reports support both audits, and a sales-rated policy draws on your profit and loss statement, sales journal or gross receipts. Look up the rating basis on your declarations page so you know which number each auditor will want.
Disputing a premium audit or class code
Audit results can be wrong, such as a clerical worker placed in the shop class or a sub charged as payroll when a certificate existed. Ask for a copy of the audit and compare it line by line with your records. State Fund, for example, accepts a dispute only in writing, with a specific account of what is wrong, what the figures should be and copies of the original records behind it. While it reviews, other bills still have to be paid on time to keep the policy in force.
For classification disputes, CDI describes two routes. You can complain in writing to the insurer and then appeal to the Department, or send a written inquiry to the WCIRB, follow with a Complaint and Request for Action if the inquiry is denied or goes unanswered for 90 days, and appeal to the Department if the WCIRB rejects or does not act on that complaint within 30 days. The detailed procedures sit in Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations, sections 2509.40 to 2509.78, and CDI also lists audit disputes among the rating problems it helps employers sort out.
If an audit bill looks out of line, send us the audit report and your payroll records. We compare the codes and payroll with what the business actually did and help you put the questions to the insurer, which decides whether to revise the audit.
What happens if you skip the audit
Ignoring audit letters is expensive. CDI says failing to comply with an insurer’s audit can lead to cancellation or non-renewal, and an employer that does not allow the audit may owe a total premium of three times the estimated policy premium. State Fund adds that it may estimate the final premium itself, which can mean more premium due, and that a cancellation can hurt your experience modifier. The WCIRB can also issue an experience mod from your reported losses while leaving out payroll that was never audited.
CDI treats deliberate underreporting of payroll as insurance fraud, so the estimate on your application should be an honest best figure. An accurate estimate, tidy records and mid-year updates are the steps from how to save on workers’ comp that pay off most at audit time.
A few useful answers
Common questions
What is a workers comp audit?
It is the insurer’s review, after the policy term, of the payroll you actually paid in each class code. The audited figures replace your estimate, so the final premium turns into either a bill for more or a refund.
How far back can a workers’ comp insurer audit my payroll?
CDI says insurers generally may audit payroll during the policy period and within three years after it ends. The WCIRB has a separate right to audit an employer’s payroll records.
What does a State Fund audit ask for?
State Fund’s checklist covers payroll registers, DE 9 and DE 9C returns, Forms 941 and 1099, a list of officers, clerical and outside sales staff with their duties, and certificates of insurance for subcontractors. The appointment letter names anything extra for your policy.
Why did my audit add payroll for a subcontractor?
Usually the auditor saw no certificate showing the sub carried its own workers’ comp, or no valid license where one was required. Send the missing certificates, with dates covering the work, in a written dispute backed by your records.
Can Mithril1 find new workers’ comp after a large audit bill?
That is possible once another insurer has reviewed your audited payroll, the work your crews do and your claims history and agrees to offer terms. We request quotes with class codes that match the duties your people actually perform.
