Hold Harmless and Indemnity Clauses
A hold harmless or indemnity clause promises that your business will pay for someone else’s losses. This guide explains how that promise meets your insurance, so you know which questions to bring to your agent and which to bring to your attorney.
What a hold harmless or indemnity clause asks of you
The NAIC’s insurance glossary describes a hold harmless agreement as a contract in which one party takes on another party’s liability. In practice the clause sits a few paragraphs above the insurance exhibit in a lease, a subcontract, a vendor agreement or a facility use contract. An indemnification clause usually has you agree to indemnify, defend and hold the other side harmless for claims arising out of your work, your products or your use of their property.
Read that way, the clause creates a debt that only appears after a loss. Your insurance is what pays it, if the policy recognizes the promise. The insurance questions are therefore concrete: does the liability policy treat this agreement as one it covers, what does it leave out, and how does the clause fit with the additional insured and waiver requests in the same contract? Our guide to insurance requirements in client contracts covers the rest of that exhibit.
Contractual liability insurance inside a general liability policy
Most businesses with general liability already hold contractual liability insurance without buying it separately, because it is built into the standard commercial general liability form. ISO’s CG 00 01 form excludes injury or damage you owe only because you assumed liability in a contract, and then makes two exceptions: liability you would have had anyway, and liability assumed in an “insured contract,” as long as the injury or damage happens after the agreement was signed.
The form lists six kinds of insured contract: a lease of premises, a sidetrack agreement, an easement or license agreement, an indemnity of a municipality required by ordinance, an elevator maintenance agreement, and the broad catch-all, the part of any other contract tied to your business under which you assume another party’s tort liability for bodily injury or property damage to a third person. Tort liability there means liability the law would impose without any contract. IRMI’s glossary notes that this definition is how a CGL extends some coverage to an enforceable hold harmless provision in a commercial contract. Our general liability page covers the policy as a whole.
Where contractual coverage stops
The catch-all covers injury and damage to third parties, not every promise a contract can hold. A client who sues because you missed a deadline or did not deliver what was promised is bringing a breach-of-contract claim, and the Texas Department of Insurance’s liability guide notes those damages are typically not covered. The form also carves out indemnity of a railroad for construction near its tracks and of architects, engineers or surveyors for their own professional work, and the lease exception leaves out the part of a lease that indemnifies for fire damage to premises rented to you.
The bigger question is fault. A broad clause may ask you to cover losses the other party caused entirely by itself. ISO’s CG 24 26 endorsement, introduced in 2004, narrows the insured contract definition to injury or damage caused, in whole or in part, by you or those acting for you. If your policy carries that endorsement, a promise to pay for the other side’s sole negligence sits outside your coverage even where the contract asks for it. Ask your agent whether CG 24 26 or a similar insurer form is on your policy before you sign.
Additional insured status and a hold harmless work differently
An indemnity clause is your promise to pay. Additional insured status is something else: an endorsement that makes the other party an insured under your policy, so it can ask your insurer for a defense directly. Many contracts ask for both, and each fills a gap the other leaves. If the indemnity promise turns out to be unenforceable or uninsured, the additional insured endorsement may still respond; if the endorsement’s scope is narrow, the contractual coverage may pick up some of the rest.
The two now track each other closely. ISO’s CG 20 10 04 13 covers the additional insured only for injury or damage caused, in whole or in part, by your work, only to the extent the law permits, and no more broadly than the contract requires. The additional insured endorsements guide explains those forms, the guide to certificate holder vs additional insured shows why a certificate alone does neither job, and our waiver of subrogation guide covers the clause that usually sits next to them.
California Civil Code 2782 and construction indemnity
California sets limits on indemnity in construction contracts, and they shape what an insurer is ever asked to pay. California Civil Code 2782(a) makes void any construction contract provision that indemnifies the promisee for its own sole negligence or willful misconduct, or for design defects it furnished, while leaving insurance contracts themselves untouched. Subdivision (b) voids provisions that shift a public agency’s active negligence onto the contractor, and for contracts on or after January 1, 2013 that protection reaches subcontractors and suppliers too. Subdivision (c) makes such provisions unenforceable to the extent of a private owner’s active negligence, with an exception for a homeowner improving their own single-family home.
Residential work has its own rules. Under subdivision (d), for residential construction contracts entered into after January 1, 2009, a clause requiring a subcontractor to insure, indemnify or defend the builder or general contractor is unenforceable to the extent the claim comes from the builder’s own negligence or design, or falls outside the sub’s written scope of work, and the parties cannot waive that. Subdivision (e) starts a residential sub’s defense duty only on a written tender of the claim. Separately, section 2782.05 limits what a non-residential subcontractor can be made to indemnify for contracts from 2013 onward, excludes wrap-up programs, and still allows contracts to require insurance, including additional insured endorsements. Subcontractors will find the practical side on our insurance for subcontractors page.
A hold harmless agreement in California: the insurance review
Before signing a hold harmless agreement in California, run two reviews side by side. Your attorney reads the clause and tells you what it means and whether its wording holds up, since drafting and interpreting indemnity language is legal work. The insurance review asks narrower questions: is this agreement an insured contract under your policy, does a CG 24 26 or similar endorsement narrow it, do the additional insured forms you carry match the ones the contract names, and do your limits, including any commercial umbrella, meet the amounts the contract states?
Send us the indemnity clause and the insurance exhibit together. We compare them with your policy forms and point out where the contract asks for more than the policy shows. If a gap appears, we request quotes for the endorsement or limit it calls for, and the insurer decides after reviewing your operations and the contract.
A few useful answers
Common questions
Does general liability cover a hold harmless agreement?
Often, in part. A standard CGL covers bodily injury and property damage liability you assume in an insured contract, signed before the loss. Breach-of-contract damages, professional services carve-outs and, where an endorsement narrows the definition, the other party’s sole negligence fall outside it.
What is contractual liability insurance?
It is coverage for liability your business takes on by agreeing in a contract to pay for someone else’s losses. In most commercial general liability policies it comes built in through the insured contract definition rather than as a separate policy.
What does California Civil Code 2782 say about indemnity for sole negligence?
Section 2782(a) makes void any construction contract provision that indemnifies a party for its own sole negligence or willful misconduct, or for defects in the design it supplied. Other subdivisions add limits for public agencies, private owners and residential subcontracts. An attorney should read how they apply to your contract.
Is an indemnification clause the same as being an additional insured?
No. An indemnification clause is your promise to pay the other party’s losses, backed by your contractual coverage. Additional insured status is an endorsement that puts the other party on your policy so it can claim directly. Contracts frequently ask for both.
Can Mithril1 write or review the wording of my hold harmless clause?
We stay on the insurance side. An attorney should draft or review the contract language, and we check how your policy responds to it and request any endorsement or higher limit the contract calls for, which the insurer then reviews.
