Skip to content

Resources

Primary and Noncontributory vs. Waiver of Subrogation

When a contract asks for primary and noncontributory coverage and a waiver of subrogation, it is asking your insurance two separate questions. Here is what each clause does, how the two differ, and how to make sure your policy says what the contract asks before you sign.

Get a quote

Two clauses, two different jobs

The waiver of subrogation vs. primary and noncontributory question comes up because the two phrases sit side by side in so many insurance clauses. They are easy to treat as one request. They are not, and knowing which is which makes it far easier to answer a client, landlord or general contractor with the right paperwork.

The short version: primary and noncontributory decides whose policy pays first and whether the other policy chips in. A waiver of subrogation decides whether the insurer that paid can later sue the other party to get its money back. One sets the order of payment; the other closes off the recovery claim afterward.

What primary and noncontributory means

On a general liability policy, primary and noncontributory treatment comes from ISO form CG 20 01, titled Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance Condition. It amends the policy’s Other Insurance condition in Section IV. For an additional insured, where a written contract requires it, your policy pays first (primary) and does not ask the additional insured’s own policy to share the loss (noncontributory).

The condition applies when the additional insured is a named insured on a policy of its own and a written contract or agreement calls for this treatment. Without it, the other insurance wording in each policy can lead the two insurers to split the loss pro rata, which can fall short of what the contract promised.

CG 20 01 does not add anyone to your policy by itself. It works alongside an additional insured endorsement, such as CG 20 10 for ongoing operations or CG 20 37 for completed operations.

What a waiver of subrogation means

Subrogation is the insurer’s right, after paying a claim, to recover what it paid from whoever caused the loss. On general liability, ISO form CG 24 04, Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us, gives that right up toward a named party. Once the claim is paid, your insurer will not pursue that person or company to get the money back.

The waiver protects only the parties scheduled or described on the endorsement, and the description often reads “where required by written contract.” Workers’ compensation waivers come from separate workers’ comp endorsements, and state rules for them vary, so check that policy on its own. Our guide to the waiver of subrogation covers where these requests turn up in leases and service contracts.

Side by side

Here is how the two general liability endorsements compare on the points a contract reviewer cares about.

QuestionPrimary and noncontributoryWaiver of subrogation
What it decidesWhose policy pays first, and whether the other party’s policy has to chip inWhether your insurer, after paying a claim, can go after the other party to recover that money
When it appliesWhen the additional insured has its own policy and a written contract calls for primary and noncontributory treatmentAfter your insurer has paid, toward the parties scheduled or described in the endorsement
General liability formISO CG 20 01, Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance ConditionISO CG 24 04, Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us
Who it protectsThe additional insured, whose own policy stays out of the lossThe scheduled person or company, who will not face a recovery claim from your insurer

Why contracts ask for both, plus additional insured status

A client that writes all three into its contract is closing three gaps at once. Additional insured status puts the client inside your policy for claims arising from your work. Primary and noncontributory wording makes your policy answer first, so the client’s own insurance stays out of it. The waiver of subrogation keeps your insurer from turning around and suing the client after it pays.

Each piece is its own endorsement, so a policy can carry one and miss the others. The same contract usually names the limits it expects as well; our guide to per-occurrence and aggregate limits explains how those two numbers work, and the client contract requirements guide walks through the rest of a typical insurance clause.

How to check a certificate request

Both terms show up on certificates of insurance, but a certificate does not change the policy. The endorsement attached to the policy is what gives the other party primary and noncontributory treatment or a waiver. Before you send a certificate, run through these steps.

  • Copy the insurance clause and mark every line that mentions additional insured, primary, noncontributory, waiver or subrogation.
  • Note which policies each request applies to: general liability, auto, workers’ compensation or umbrella.
  • Ask your broker to confirm that each endorsement the contract calls for is on the policy, and to send the endorsement pages.
  • Check that the party named in the contract fits the endorsement’s schedule or its written-contract description.
  • Then request the certificate, with the endorsement pages attached.

Asking a vendor or subcontractor for the same proof? Our certificate of insurance request letter templates ask for the endorsements by name, and the certificate of insurance guide explains how to read what comes back.

Get help

Mithril1 is a California insurance broker. Send us the insurance section of your lease or contract and we will go through each request with you, then look for coverage that lines up with it once an insurer has reviewed your business. Contact Mithril1 to get started. This guide is general information, not legal advice on your contract.

A few useful answers

Common questions

What is the difference between a waiver of subrogation and primary and noncontributory?

Primary and noncontributory sets the payment order: your policy answers first and does not ask the other party’s insurer to share the loss. A waiver of subrogation stops your insurer, once it has paid, from suing that party to recover its money.

Does primary and noncontributory wording make someone an additional insured?

No. Form CG 20 01 only changes how your policy treats an additional insured. The party is added through a separate additional insured endorsement, such as CG 20 10 for ongoing operations or CG 20 37 for completed operations.

Is a certificate of insurance proof of a waiver or primary and noncontributory coverage?

Not on its own. A certificate summarizes coverage without changing the policy. The endorsement attached to the policy is what grants the waiver or primary treatment, so ask your broker to confirm it is there and send the endorsement page.

Who does a waiver of subrogation protect?

Only the people or companies scheduled or described on the endorsement. Many forms describe them as anyone you agreed in a written contract to waive recovery against, which makes the contract itself the key document.

What happens if my policy lacks primary and noncontributory wording?

Each policy’s other insurance condition can lead the insurers to split the loss pro rata. That falls short of a contract that asked your policy to pay first without help from the other party’s policy.

Does a workers’ comp policy use the same waiver form?

No. CG 24 04 is a general liability form. A workers’ comp waiver of subrogation comes from a separate workers’ comp endorsement, and state rules for it vary, so review that policy with your broker on its own.